The Impact of Child Benefit Repayment Shift to PAYE from Summer 2025 in the Spring Statement 2025
- MAZ
- Apr 7
- 23 min read
Index:
PAYE Takes Over: What the HICBC Shift Means for Employed Parents
Navigating Refunds, Emergencies, and Overpayments Under PAYE for HICBC
The PAYE Shift and Its Ripple Effects on Employers and Payroll Operations
Digital Tax: How Tech Is Streamlining the HICBC Experience for Families
From Burden to Benefit: How the HICBC Reform Fits into the UK’s Bigger Tax Strategy
The Audio Summary of the Key Points of the Article:
PAYE Takes Over: What the HICBC Shift Means for Employed Parents
A Tax Revolution for Working Families
From summer 2025, thousands of UK families will experience a significant shake-up in how the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) is collected. If you or your partner earns over £60,000 and receives Child Benefit, you’ll know the pain of filing a Self Assessment tax return—even when it’s the only reason you’re doing so. But that’s all about to change.
Thanks to the Spring Statement 2025 and HMRC’s drive to “cut red tape,” you’ll soon be able to settle your HICBC automatically through PAYE—just like income tax or National Insurance. This means no more tax returns for thousands of employed taxpayers. Hey, don’t sweat it—we’re breaking it all down below with examples, numbers, and real-life impacts so you know exactly what to expect.
Let’s start with the fundamentals...
What Is the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC)?
The basics of the benefit clawback
The HICBC was introduced in January 2013 to recoup Child Benefit from higher earners. It applies when either partner in a household earns over a set threshold, regardless of who receives the Child Benefit.
Taxpayer’s Adjusted Net Income | Repayment of Child Benefit |
£60,000 or less | No repayment |
£60,001 to £80,000 | Partial repayment (1% per £100) |
Over £80,000 | Full repayment |
Adjusted Net Income is your total taxable income minus things like Gift Aid and pension contributions.
As of April 2024, the thresholds changed from £50k–£60k to £60k–£80k, offering relief to thousands of middle-income households. You can calculate your HICBC liability using the official HMRC Child Benefit Tax Calculator.
The Problem with Self Assessment for HICBC
Why taxpayers have been frustrated for years
If HICBC applies to you—even by £1—you currently must register for Self Assessment, file a return annually, and pay the charge manually. This:
Adds admin burden for people who are otherwise PAYE-only,
Risks penalties if you don’t register or file on time,
Can trigger confusion over which partner is responsible,
Results in duplicate income reporting, since HMRC already has your PAYE info.
In fact, between 2021–2024, over 130,000 people received late-filing penalties tied to HICBC. The new PAYE method aims to prevent this kind of unnecessary stress.
What’s Changing in Summer 2025?
The new PAYE option, explained
From summer 2025, HICBC for employed individuals can be collected automatically via your tax code—no Self Assessment needed.
Here’s how it works:
Before Summer 2025 | From Summer 2025 (if opted in) |
Must register for Self Assessment if liable for HICBC | Can opt to pay via PAYE |
Annual tax return required | Charge spread across payslips |
One-off lump sum due by 31 Jan | Deducted monthly from salary |
Higher chance of penalties | Seamless integration with payroll |
🔔 Important: It’s optional. If you prefer filing Self Assessment or have other income sources, you can still go that route.
Who Benefits Most from the Shift?
Real-life scenarios
Let’s look at two UK families to see how this change will play out.
Case 1: Laura, a PAYE-only teacher
Salary: £72,000
Children: Two
Child Benefit received: £2,251.60/year
HICBC: 60% charge (approx. £1,350)
Under current rules, Laura has to file a tax return every year just to pay this back. But with PAYE collection:
HMRC adjusts her tax code
Roughly £112.50/month is deducted from her salary
No return needed unless other income arises
Case 2: Karim, a self-employed consultant
Salary: £90,000
Children: One
Child Benefit received: £1,354.60/year
HICBC: Full charge (100%)
Karim already files a tax return for business reasons. For him, there’s no benefit to switching, so he’ll continue reporting via Self Assessment.
PAYE Tax Code Adjustments: What to Expect
HMRC will adjust your tax code based on the estimated charge due for the year, similar to how it handles underpayments or benefits-in-kind.
Example tax code adjustment for someone owing £1,000:
Charge | Tax Code Adjustment | Monthly Impact (20%) |
£1,000 | £5,000 reduction in allowance | ~£83/month extra tax |
This ensures small, manageable deductions across the year.
📝 Tip: You can view and manage your tax code directly via your Personal Tax Account.
Child Benefit 2025 Rates and Tax Planning
With Child Benefit rates increasing from 7 April 2025, more families are opting back in:
Child | Weekly Rate (from Apr 2025) | Annual Amount |
First/only child | £26.05 | £1,354.60 |
Additional child | £17.25 | £897.00 |
Even if you repay some or all via HICBC, claiming can still be beneficial for:
National Insurance credits (especially for non-working partners),
Automatic NI number assignment for your child at age 16,
Accessing proof of benefit for other entitlements.
Key Takeaways for Employers and Payroll Teams
While the shift reduces admin for families, it does increase payroll complexity. Employers should:
Expect more coding notices from HMRC,
Educate staff about changes—especially those who opted out previously,
Be ready to handle employee queries about tax code changes.
Good payroll software should handle the adjustments automatically once HMRC sends the coding notice, but communication is key.
Child Benefit PAYE Shift & HICBC Thresholds (2020–2024) – UK Tax Reform Explained Visually
Navigating Refunds, Emergencies, and Overpayments Under PAYE for HICBC
The Devil’s in the Details
So, PAYE’s taking over HICBC from summer—but what happens when things go sideways? Overpayments, emergency tax codes, unexpected underpayments… These aren’t just tax trivia; they can mean hundreds of pounds lost or delayed.
In Part 2 of our series on the HICBC PAYE shift, we’re rolling up our sleeves to unpack the real-world nitty gritty: what could go wrong, how it impacts refunds, and what you can actually do about it.
Because let’s be honest—tax is stressful enough without surprise letters from HMRC.
Emergency Tax Codes: PAYE’s Most Common Pitfall
What they are and why they matter more now
With HICBC now feeding into PAYE, tax code accuracy becomes everything. If HMRC doesn’t get it right, your monthly take-home can take a hit—sometimes a big one.
Emergency tax codes like 1257L W1/M1 mean HMRC treats every paycheck like it’s your first one of the year—ignoring cumulative earnings. You may see too much tax deducted temporarily.
🔍 Example: Sarah earns £66,000 and is now repaying HICBC via PAYE. If she’s put on an emergency code due to a job change or HMRC delay, she might overpay hundreds in income tax and HICBC deduction until her code is fixed.
🛠️ How to fix it:
Check your tax code in your Personal Tax Account
Contact HMRC via webchat or 0300 200 3300
Get your employer to issue a corrected P45 or starter checklist
Once sorted, HMRC usually refunds automatically through payroll within 4–8 weeks.
Overpayments of HICBC: What If HMRC Gets It Wrong?
Why the PAYE shift won’t always get it perfect
PAYE relies on estimated annual income. But what if your actual earnings are lower than expected?
Imagine this:
You opt into PAYE collection in August
HMRC calculates your charge based on £70,000
But you reduce your hours in November and end up earning £58,000 total
Boom — you were never liable for HICBC, but HMRC has clawed back several months of charges through PAYE.
🧾 What happens next?
Your end-of-year tax reconciliation (P800) will trigger an automatic refund
It usually arrives between June–September after the tax year ends
You can also file a Self Assessment voluntarily to claim sooner
Underpayments and Tax Shortfalls: Hidden Risks for Late Starters
PAYE isn’t always real-time
If you opt into PAYE HICBC partway through a tax year, your remaining months must carry the full year’s charge—leading to chunky deductions.
🧮 Example:
Jamie earns £78,000, HICBC is 90%
His charge = £2,026.44 (based on two kids)
If he opts in in November, HMRC spreads that over 5 remaining pay periods
That’s £405/month, which can sting
This can feel like a pay cut if you’re not prepared. You may also get a P800 notice at year-end if PAYE didn’t deduct the full amount due.
👂 Pro tip: Check your expected charge using the Child Benefit Tax Calculator before opting in late in the year.
Refunds: How and When You’ll Get Your Money Back
Let’s be real: overpaying is one thing—waiting ages for your refund is another.
Here’s how HICBC refunds work under PAYE:
Scenario | How Refund Happens | Timeframe |
You overpay HICBC due to income drop | Auto refund via HMRC P800 | Summer (June–Sep) |
You spot an overcharge earlier | File Self Assessment voluntarily | Usually 1–2 weeks after submission |
You’ve changed jobs mid-year | May require manual request or PAYE reconciliation | 4–8 weeks |
⚠️ If you’re due a refund and it hasn’t come by October, call HMRC or check your Personal Tax Account. Refunds don’t always trigger automatically in complex PAYE cases.
PAYE Coding Notices and Communication Delays
Now that HICBC is rolling into tax codes, PAYE coding notices (P2 forms) become essential reading. They show how your Personal Allowance is being adjusted.
🧾 Look out for entries like:
“Adjustment for HICBC: -£5,000”
“Other income: -£3,200”
Your tax code will shrink as HICBC eats into your tax-free allowance.
🚨 Common issues:
HMRC uses last year’s income to guess this year’s tax code
If your income fluctuates (bonus, overtime, job switch), you can get over- or undercharged
🛡️ What you can do:
Use the Tax Code Checker
Update your estimated income in the Personal Tax Account
Ask HMRC to issue a new code if it's way off
PAYE vs Self Assessment: Which One Makes Refunds Easier?
This is where it gets a bit nuanced.
Feature | PAYE | Self Assessment |
Auto deduction | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
Immediate tax refunds | ❌ No (wait for P800) | ✅ Yes (after submission) |
Admin hassle | ✅ Minimal | ❌ High |
Flexibility for variable income | ❌ Less | ✅ More accurate |
Required for landlords/self-employed | ❌ Optional | ✅ Mandatory if other income applies |
If you have simple employment income, PAYE is a no-brainer. But if you have bonuses, freelance side hustles, rental income, or large pension contributions, Self Assessment might still give you more control—and faster corrections.
Action Plan for PAYE HICBC Users
Let’s break this down into next steps:
✅ 1. Opt into PAYE (when the option launches)
You’ll get a notification via HMRC app or your Personal Tax Account
✅ 2. Check your tax code accuracy
Look for changes and understand the reduction due to HICBC
✅ 3. Keep income estimates updated
Especially important if bonuses, overtime or maternity leave apply
✅ 4. Know when to check for refunds
If your income dips below £60k, be proactive
✅ 5. Consider voluntary Self Assessment if:
You want to reclaim overpayments quickly
You have other income sources
Your tax code looks wrong
Graphical Representation of UK Child Benefit PAYE Changes 2025
The PAYE Shift and Its Ripple Effects on Employers and Payroll Operations
Why This Isn’t Just a Family Matter
While the PAYE option for repaying the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) is framed as a win for employees, it introduces a significant shift for employers, payroll providers, and HR teams too. From new coding notices to staff confusion about net pay changes, the ripple effect of this reform reaches well beyond the family home.
This part breaks down what UK businesses and payroll professionals need to know to stay compliant, support their staff, and avoid the administrative headaches this change could bring—especially in the 2025-26 tax year and beyond.
What Employers Need to Know About the HICBC PAYE Shift
From summer, HMRC will begin issuing revised tax codes to employed individuals who choose to pay their HICBC via PAYE. These codes will reduce an employee’s personal allowance to collect the estimated tax charge throughout the year.
Employers must be prepared for:
A spike in coding notice (P6 and P9) updates
Employees questioning sudden net pay drops
Potential mismatches between HMRC’s estimated tax and real-world earnings
The need to communicate proactively to avoid confusion
This change will be handled entirely through payroll, with no need for separate employer action to initiate it. However, the quality of your internal communication, payroll system capability, and responsiveness to staff queries will matter more than ever.
How Will HMRC Communicate the Changes?
HMRC will issue P6 (in-year adjustments) and P9 (start-of-tax-year) notices to employers when a staff member opts into the PAYE HICBC collection method. These notices contain the updated tax code, reflecting the reduced personal allowance.
For example, an employee with a standard code of 1257L might receive a revised code such as 957L if they owe £600 in HICBC. The £3,000 reduction in allowance equates to an additional £600 in income tax deducted over the year, assuming a 20% tax rate.
Employers are not expected to know why the code changed—only to implement it.
However, they should be prepared to explain the mechanism to employees, especially where staff are unaware that a partner’s benefit claim can affect their take-home pay.
What This Means for Payroll Teams and Software
The good news is that modern payroll software systems such as BrightPay, Sage, QuickBooks Payroll, and Moneysoft are built to process tax code changes automatically. But that’s only half the story.
Payroll teams need to:
Reconcile any sudden tax code updates
Be alert for employee confusion about reduced take-home pay
Check for correct application of new codes, especially when mid-year changes occur
Be ready to process manual corrections or prior year adjustments (PYAs) in rare cases
For outsourced payroll providers, this also introduces customer support implications. Clients will expect rapid clarification when staff notice changes to their payslip. Clear documentation and pre-emptive advice will help reduce support requests.
HR’s Role: Managing Staff Expectations
Although the HICBC is a personal tax matter, many employees will turn to their HR department for answers. It’s critical to:
Circulate a pre-emptive HR notice explaining:
The nature of the HICBC
Why their tax code might be adjusted
Where to find help (e.g., Personal Tax Account, HMRC helpline)
Train front-line HR staff on the basics of the HICBC:
Who it applies to (income over £60,000, partner receives Child Benefit)
The purpose of tax code reductions
How PAYE collection differs from Self Assessment
Include this in onboarding and pay communication materials:
Particularly for senior hires who may earn over the threshold
Emphasise that tax code changes do not originate from employer decisions
Business Case Example: Managing Multiple Affected Staff
Consider a mid-sized firm with 500 employees, 60 of whom earn over £60,000. If even half of them opt into the PAYE HICBC system, the business will:
Receive up to 30 new coding notices mid-year
Need to reconcile increased tax deductions across multiple departments
Handle staff queries regarding unexpected reductions in pay
This could increase payroll admin hours by 10–20% during the transition quarter, especially if systems or staff aren’t fully prepared.
Employers who are proactive in training their payroll and HR teams, preparing templated responses, and updating their internal guides will weather the shift more smoothly.
Directors, Multiple Jobs, and Edge Cases
The HICBC PAYE model introduces special complications for some individuals, particularly company directors and those with multiple jobs.
Directors on Annual Payrolls
Many company directors are paid via an annual payroll, receiving a single annual salary or irregular dividends. PAYE tax coding in these cases can be difficult to apply correctly because:
HMRC may not spread the charge evenly if there's only one pay period
Over- or under-deductions are more likely
Manual reconciliation or Self Assessment may still be required
Multiple Employments
Employees with more than one job may see the HICBC charge applied only to their main job’s code, even if that causes excessive deductions or tax inefficiencies.
In such cases:
HMRC may attempt to spread the charge, but this isn’t always automatic
Employees can request specific coding via their Personal Tax Account
Complex situations may require Self Assessment to balance properly
Employers must be prepared to assist staff in understanding these nuances and, if necessary, direct them to HMRC for correction.
Staff Leaving Mid-Year: Who Picks Up the Slack?
Another quirk: when an employee leaves partway through the year, but has already had partial HICBC deductions through PAYE, there’s a risk of:
Over-collection, if income ends up below the threshold
Under-collection, if deductions were incomplete
In these cases, HMRC typically reconciles via a P800 statement the following year. However, the employer’s obligation ends at the point of final payroll. Staff must chase HMRC directly for refunds or top-ups.
Recommended Employer Actions Before Summer Rollout
To stay ahead of the curve, UK employers should consider the following immediate steps:
Audit payroll systems to ensure full tax code compatibility
Establish a central contact point for employee tax code queries
Coordinate with HR to prepare briefing materials for staff
Create a tax notice communication plan, particularly for high earners
Engage your payroll software provider about mid-year update processes
This is a one-off adjustment with ongoing implications, so the initial preparation will pay off for years to come.
Summary: More Admin Today, Less Chaos Tomorrow
For employers, the HICBC PAYE shift isn’t about making tax easier—it’s about making tax smoother for staff and more predictable over time. While the initial adjustment period may feel bumpy, once tax codes stabilize, the long-term benefit is clear: fewer late filings, fewer penalties, and less stress for employees and HR teams alike.
Graphical Representation of Child Benefit PAYE Shift & HICBC Thresholds (2020–2024)
Digital Tax: How Tech Is Streamlining the HICBC Experience for Families
Introduction: From Paper to Pocket—Tax Goes Digital
If there’s one thing taxpayers and businesses can agree on, it’s this: tax admin has historically been a hassle. Long wait times, clunky paper forms, confusing processes—sound familiar?
With the shift of the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) to PAYE from summer, HMRC is also pushing a digital-first strategy to modernise how families interact with their Child Benefit and tax affairs. In this part, we explore how tools like the HMRC app, the Personal Tax Account, and automation features are reshaping the tax landscape—not just for the HICBC, but for everything from benefit claims to refunds.
HMRC’s App: A Game Changer for Parents
The HMRC mobile app, available free on both Android and iOS, has quietly become a cornerstone of this new system. As of early 2025:
Over 1.2 million parents have claimed Child Benefit using the app
More than 87% of new claims are now digital
Parents can manage payments, track status, and update details in real-time
Here’s what you can do through the app:
Feature | Functionality |
New claims | Submit application within 10 minutes |
Status tracking | Get confirmation and updates via push notifications |
Change details | Add children, update addresses, switch bank info |
Opt in/out | Restart payments or stop them based on income |
Download documents | Access proof of entitlement for other benefits |
This means no waiting for letters, no calling HMRC, and no missing deadlines because a form got lost in the post.
Personal Tax Account: Your Online Tax Dashboard
If the app is your pocket tool, the Personal Tax Account (PTA) is the control centre.
Accessible at www.gov.uk/personal-tax-account, it lets taxpayers:
View and update tax codes
Check income figures and employment history
Adjust estimated income used by HMRC
View HICBC charges and PAYE adjustments
Check National Insurance contributions and credits
It’s where the HICBC PAYE election will likely be managed, once the system rolls out in summer. Parents will be prompted with an option to move their HICBC repayment to PAYE directly from their PTA dashboard.
Automation in Action: How PAYE Links to HMRC Systems
Behind the scenes, HMRC is using a range of digital integrations to power this change:
Real-time information (RTI) feeds from employers help HMRC track income
Algorithms adjust tax codes mid-year based on known income trends
The PAYE system is designed to spread repayment of HICBC evenly once a person opts in, reducing large surprise bills
Automation means that less manual intervention is needed—but it also means taxpayers must ensure their income estimates are accurate.
Let’s say your income changes in October due to a new job. If your PTA still shows last year’s income of £75,000, but you’re now earning £58,000, HMRC will continue deducting based on the old figure—unless you update it yourself.
Opting In and Out of PAYE for HICBC: The Digital Process
Once the PAYE system is live, eligible parents will see new prompts in their PTA or receive letters encouraging them to opt in.
The process will look something like this:
Login to your Personal Tax Account
Navigate to “Manage Child Benefit”
Select “Pay HICBC through PAYE”
Confirm or update your expected income
Review the estimated charge
Submit the election
After submission, HMRC will send a coding notice to your employer within weeks, adjusting your tax code to include the charge.
You can opt out again at any time, and revert to Self Assessment if you later need to file for other income sources or prefer managing everything manually.
How Fast Are Refunds and Adjustments via Digital Services?
Digital interaction also speeds up refunds and corrections. Let’s look at how the timelines differ.
Action | Paper Process | Digital Process |
Child Benefit claim | 4–6 weeks | As little as 3 working days |
Change of circumstance | 2–4 weeks | Immediate (via app or PTA) |
Tax code update | 4–6 weeks | Typically within 2–3 weeks |
HICBC refund | Post-year via cheque or manual | Online via P800 or bank deposit |
The move to digital also reduces human error—no need to chase lost forms or resend supporting documents by post.
Common Digital Pitfalls to Avoid
Even digital systems aren’t foolproof. Here's where families need to stay alert:
Incorrect partner declared as higher earnerHICBC applies to the partner with the highest adjusted net income, regardless of who gets the benefit. Entering the wrong income during digital opt-in could assign liability incorrectly.
Outdated income estimatesHMRC relies on taxpayer-supplied estimates unless they receive updated RTI from employers. If your PTA shows £68,000 but your raise pushes you to £75,000, you could underpay and owe extra later.
Incompatible employers or payroll softwareWhile rare, some smaller payroll providers may experience delays implementing coding notices, leading to under-collection.
Multiple job complicationsThe PTA may not reflect combined earnings immediately if RTI feeds haven’t synced. This can cause incomplete HICBC deductions.
Support for Vulnerable or Offline Families
While HMRC is going digital-first, the system still accommodates those who:
Lack internet access
Have accessibility needs
Prefer paper-based communication
HMRC has confirmed that paper-based Self Assessment for HICBC will remain available indefinitely, and that the new digital system is optional, not mandatory.
Families can also call the HMRC helpline or access community tax clinics in partnership with Citizens Advice and similar charities.
Tech Upgrades on the Horizon
HMRC’s digital reform plans don’t stop with Child Benefit. Future developments include:
A dedicated Child Benefit dashboard with alerts and benefit history
Enhanced open banking integration for instant income verification
Real-time tax code editing
Full integration between PTA and employer RTI feeds
Expanded digital identity login via GOV.UK One Login (replacing Government Gateway)
These changes are aimed at creating a frictionless tax experience, especially for PAYE-only taxpayers who want to avoid annual returns entirely.
What Families Should Do Now
If you or your partner expects to earn over £60,000 and you receive Child Benefit, here’s how to prepare:
Register for the Personal Tax Account
Download the HMRC app
Claim Child Benefit digitally, if not already done
Use the Child Benefit Tax Calculator to estimate your charge
Sign up for email alerts from HMRC so you’re notified when PAYE opt-in opens
Preparing now ensures you can opt in on day one and avoid unnecessary admin next tax year.
From Burden to Benefit: How the HICBC Reform Fits into the UK’s Bigger Tax Strategy
The Bigger Picture
At first glance, the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) PAYE reform might look like a small tweak—a nice convenience for higher-earning families. But when you zoom out, it’s actually part of a larger shift in how the UK manages taxation and welfare delivery.
In this final part, we’ll explore how this reform connects to wider tax system modernisation, what it means for future tax strategy, and how families and business owners alike can use it to streamline finances, reduce penalties, and gain more control over their financial planning. We’ll also look at the longer-term implications for the government, employers, and the structure of benefits in the UK.
The End of Self Assessment for the Middle Class?
For years, tens of thousands of taxpayers have been dragged into the Self Assessment system only because they crossed the HICBC threshold. They had no rental income, no dividends, no side business—just a regular job and a household that received Child Benefit.
This created a significant admin burden:
Filing a full tax return for a single calculation
Navigating registration, deadlines, and penalties
Risk of £100 late-filing fines for missing deadlines
The PAYE reform, confirmed in the Spring Statement 2025, effectively removes this burden for most salaried taxpayers.
This is consistent with the government’s long-term tax simplification agenda—a key plank of its Plan for Change strategy to reduce friction and improve compliance.
According to HMRC data:
Over 375,000 Self Assessment returns in 2023–24 were filed solely due to HICBC
Eliminating these cases via PAYE could cut compliance costs by millions annually
It frees up HMRC resources to focus on complex cases and enforcement
How Business Owners Can Integrate the Reform into Tax Planning
For directors and entrepreneurs, the HICBC reform presents an opportunity to rethink salary and dividend planning, especially when Child Benefit is in play.
Consider the following strategies:
Keep Adjusted Net Income Just Below the Threshold
With the new £60,000 threshold now in place, it may make sense to cap salary or dividend withdrawals to £59,999 per annum.
You can achieve this through:
Employer pension contributions (excluded from adjusted net income)
Salary sacrifice arrangements for things like EV leases or childcare
Careful dividend timing and profit deferral
Use Pension Contributions to Offset HICBC Liability
Because HICBC is based on adjusted net income, personal pension contributions can reduce the charge. For example:
Earn £65,000? Contribute £5,000 to a pension.
Your adjusted income becomes £60,000.
You avoid the charge entirely and still receive Child Benefit in full.
This approach is especially useful for family businesses or consultants with flexible remuneration structures.
Consider Family Income Distribution
If you’re in a dual-director household, it might be worth splitting income more evenly to keep both partners under the threshold.
For example:
One partner earning £100,000 triggers full HICBC
Two partners earning £50,000 each avoids it entirely
Of course, this must be commercially justifiable and documented appropriately, especially for limited companies.
The Broader Welfare Reform Agenda
The HICBC PAYE shift is not happening in isolation. It’s part of a broader rethinking of benefit delivery and means testing in the UK.
Key developments include:
Digital Universal Credit integrations, with more real-time income assessments
National Insurance reform, potentially to merge income tax and NI in future
A push toward a unified household income model, which could impact eligibility for a range of benefits
There are growing calls for the HICBC to be abolished entirely and replaced with a system based on household income, not individual thresholds.
Currently, this is under review, with a potential consultation expected in 2025–26. For now, the PAYE reform is seen as a pragmatic step while policymakers debate the deeper structural changes.
What This Means for Financial Advisors and Accountants
For tax professionals, the implications are twofold:
Reduction in Self Assessment clients who only file due to HICBC
Increased demand for mid-year tax code reviews, coding adjustments, and digital support
Advisors will also need to:
Understand the PAYE HICBC process to guide clients during the transition
Help high-income families plan contributions and salary structures effectively
Flag scenarios where clients might still need Self Assessment, even with the PAYE option available (e.g. rental income, capital gains)
There’s also an emerging market for digital tax services and tools that help clients check income levels, adjust codes, and monitor HICBC liabilities in real time.
Summary Table: Who Benefits Most from the HICBC PAYE Shift?
Taxpayer Type | Impact of PAYE HICBC Shift |
PAYE-only employees | Major benefit – no more returns |
Self-employed | No change – still file Self Assessment |
Directors with low salary, high dividends | Mixed impact – may still need planning |
Employers with >£60k earners | Admin increase, especially mid-year |
Tax advisors | Fewer HICBC-only returns, more planning consultations |
Final Thoughts: Tax, Simplified
This reform is ultimately about making life easier for families who have, for years, been overburdened by an outdated tax mechanism. It delivers:
Fairness: Fewer people penalised for technical errors or forgotten returns
Clarity: No more wondering how or when to pay the charge
Efficiency: HMRC reduces admin, and taxpayers save time and money
But more than that, it reflects a wider push toward a more responsive, digital-first, taxpayer-friendly system—one where routine obligations are handled automatically, and individuals and businesses are empowered with the data and tools to make smart decisions.
Final Call to Action for UK Taxpayers
Whether you’re a parent, a business owner, or a tax advisor, the message is clear:
Check your income against the £60,000 threshold
Register for a Personal Tax Account if you haven’t already
Prepare to opt into PAYE collection this summer
Use planning strategies to stay efficient, legal, and stress-free
Talk to a professional if your situation is complex
The days of filing an entire tax return just to repay Child Benefit are numbered. And that’s a win for almost everyone.
Summary of All the Most Important Points Mentioned In the Above Article
From summer 2025, employed individuals can opt to repay the High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) via PAYE instead of filing a Self Assessment tax return.
The HICBC threshold increased to £60,000 in April 2024, with the full charge applying at £80,000 or more.
PAYE collection will be optional and spread the charge across monthly pay, reducing lump-sum tax bills and penalties.
Emergency tax codes and income estimate errors could lead to temporary overpayments or underpayments under PAYE.
HMRC will reconcile overpaid or underpaid HICBC via P800 statements, or taxpayers can file a voluntary Self Assessment to correct issues sooner.
Employers must handle increased tax code adjustments and employee queries but are not responsible for calculating the charge.
The HMRC app and Personal Tax Account allow families to manage Child Benefit, track income, and opt into PAYE digitally.
Business owners can mitigate or avoid HICBC by using pension contributions, income splitting, or keeping income under the £60,000 threshold.
The reform aligns with the government’s wider digital and tax simplification strategy, aiming to reduce unnecessary tax returns and admin costs.
While PAYE simplifies repayment for many, complex earners or those with additional income may still require Self Assessment and tax planning.
FAQs
Q1. Will you be automatically enrolled in PAYE HICBC repayment or do you need to opt in?
A1. You will not be automatically enrolled; you must actively opt into PAYE-based HICBC collection via your Personal Tax Account once the service becomes available in summer 2025.
Q2. What happens if you earn just over £60,000 but your income varies month to month?
A2. PAYE HICBC deductions are based on estimated annual income, so if your income fluctuates, you may be over- or undercharged until HMRC reconciles your actual year-end income.
Q3. Can you opt into PAYE repayment for HICBC mid-tax year?
A3. Yes, you can opt in at any point during the tax year, but this may lead to higher deductions for the remaining months to cover the full annual charge.
Q4. How will you know if HMRC has applied the HICBC to your tax code?
A4. You will receive a tax coding notice (P2) from HMRC and can view your updated tax code in your Personal Tax Account or HMRC app.
Q5. Can you switch back from PAYE to Self Assessment for HICBC repayment if needed?
A5. Yes, switching back is allowed, but you must inform HMRC before the Self Assessment deadline to avoid penalties or duplicate charges.
Q6. What should you do if you opted out of Child Benefit and now want to restart it under PAYE?
A6. You can opt back in via the HMRC app or online account, and begin receiving payments again, even if you expect to repay some or all via PAYE.
Q7. Will HICBC under PAYE apply to bonuses or only to your base salary?
A7. It applies to total adjusted net income, including bonuses, so if these raise your income above the threshold, the charge still applies through PAYE.
Q8. Is the PAYE HICBC repayment available to people on fixed-term or part-year contracts?A8. Yes, but if you're employed only part of the year, you may be overcharged unless you update your income estimate or file a reconciliation after the year ends.
Q9. What happens if you change jobs during the year after opting into PAYE HICBC collection?
A9. Your new employer will apply the updated tax code from HMRC, but there could be temporary delays or discrepancies during the transition.
Q10. Will your partner also need to take any action for PAYE HICBC deductions to apply to you?
A10. No, the charge is applied solely to the higher earner's tax code; your partner doesn’t need to take any action unless they are the higher earner.
Q11. Can you view how much HICBC has been deducted through PAYE during the year?
A11. Yes, the deduction appears on your payslip under tax code adjustments, and you can also view the total in your Personal Tax Account.
Q12. Will PAYE HICBC repayment be visible to mortgage lenders or impact credit scores?A12. No, these deductions are part of your normal income tax and are not visible to credit reference agencies or lenders in credit reports.
Q13. What happens if your employer fails to apply the tax code update for HICBC?
A13. HMRC will eventually reconcile this through your tax record, but you may face underpayments or be asked to repay through future tax code adjustments or Self Assessment.
Q14. Will employees in Scotland and Wales be affected differently by the HICBC PAYE change?
A14. No, the change applies UK-wide, although tax rates and bands may differ slightly depending on your residency, the mechanism for HICBC collection remains the same.
Q15. Can you prevent HMRC from collecting HICBC via PAYE if you prefer annual settlement?
A15. Yes, PAYE collection is optional; you can decline it and continue paying the charge via your Self Assessment return.
Q16. Will you receive confirmation once HICBC PAYE deductions begin?
A16. Yes, HMRC will send confirmation once your election is processed, and your employer applies the updated code—visible on your payslip within 1–2 payroll cycles.
Q17. Can you challenge HMRC’s HICBC income estimate used for your tax code adjustment?
A17. Yes, you can update your estimated income manually in your Personal Tax Account to correct any overestimated figures.
Q18. What happens to HICBC payments via PAYE if you take maternity or unpaid leave?
A18. Deductions will reduce or pause if your pay drops, but underpayments may arise, which HMRC will reconcile after the tax year ends.
Q19. Are employers legally required to explain the HICBC PAYE deduction to employees?
A19. No, but many do provide basic information to employees as part of payroll communication to help reduce confusion and support transparency.
Q20. Can you still receive National Insurance credits if you opt out of Child Benefit payments but claim the benefit?
A20. Yes, claiming Child Benefit—even without receiving payments—still entitles you to NI credits, which count towards your State Pension.
Disclaimer:
The information provided in our articles is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as professional advice. While we strive to keep the information up-to-date and correct, My Tax Accountant makes no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the website or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained in the articles for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.
We encourage all readers to consult with a qualified professional before making any decisions based on the information provided. The tax and accounting rules in the UK are subject to change and can vary depending on individual circumstances. Therefore, My Tax Accountant cannot be held liable for any errors, omissions, or inaccuracies published. The firm is not responsible for any losses, injuries, or damages arising from the display or use of this information.
Comments